I have always (ever since I became old enough to think about it at any rate) believed that formal higher education is not worth the money. As I was doing some Web browsing one evening, I ran across this report, ‘The Dorm Key Ritual’, from respected Christian economist and historian Gary North. It is always nice to have one’s opinions confirmed by an expert.
Dr North gives an economical insight into the cost of an on-campus college or university education, exposes the marketing strategies used to sell such an education, and reveals the startling facts about the more efficient, faster, higher quality alternatives.
It is my opinion that an excellent education–‘higher’ or otherwise–requires only a few ingredients:
1. A student, possessing a mind. It is best if this item comes with a fair degree of intelligence, motivation and industry.
2. Books. Or to be a little broader in these days of high-speed Internet, reading material.
3. Paper. This is to be written or typed upon.
4. Pencils or other writing implements. If you prefer, this may be replaced with a keyboard.
A lifetime of reading and thought, with a bit of writing thrown for good measure. If you’ll excuse me, I’ll go work on that.
June 22, 2008 at 5:21 am
Hey Emily! Happy to see you back on your blog; I’ve really been enjoying reading it.
Hmm…the article was very interesting. I think he made some EXCELLENT points. But I disagreed with the use of such extreme analogies. I mean, I know true Christian colleges are few and far between, but they do exist. North seemed to be implying that there was no college or university that was not a cesspool of Marxism, Atheism or Feminism. Granted, most Christian colleges are very expensive, and from that stems the problems with government grants. But if a Christian college were available to you, free of the burden of student loans or grants, would you attend?
I hope you don’t think I’m rude; these are issues that I have been dealing with recently, as graduation is approaching, so they’ve been on my mind a great deal. I would love to hear more of your thoughts on issues such as these.
Hope to hear from you soon!
In Christ,
Bonnie Mae
June 25, 2008 at 4:40 am
Sorry it took me so long to get back to you.
So . . . . would I go to a Christian college if one were available? The short answer is no. In the first place, I would not live away from home, even for part of the week. Even if said college was within commuting distance, I probably still wouldn’t go. I have yet to here of one college, Christian, conservative, or otherwise, that I would not problems with. I have friends who have attended ‘conservative, Christian’ colleges who say that they were taught feministic, socialised (if that’s the right word), revisionist versions of history and literature–is there even one college in America that does not teach that ‘Honest Abe’ and Michael King were great, freedom-loving Christian heroes? Many Christian colleges allow their professors to teach erroneous philosophies as well.
Also, as an auto-didactic, real-books oriented learner I don’t care much for the college teaching style, but that’s not really a major factor in this decision.
So no, even if other problems were set aside, I personally would not attend a Christian college.
About a year ago I wrote an article detailing the major reasons for this decision: http://lesriley.net/college_girls.htm
Later there was some discussion (largely between myself and Laura) on my daddy’s message board: http://www.lesriley.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=541
Any other questions/thoughts are welcome!
~Emma
June 25, 2008 at 9:07 am
Thanks for taking the time to reply. I can certainly understand your reasoning and respect your opinion; it’s obvious that you’ve thought this through very deeply. Though, as you could probably guess, I tend to agree with Laura on this issue.
But I am interested in hearing people’s reasons for their beliefs, and so I appreciate your time.
Completely changing the subject, I remember one of your earlier posts about Wives and Daughters. That set me to thinking about period dramas, and I was going to ask you if you had seen the adaptation of Our Mutual Friend, by Dickens. I recently watched it a few weeks ago and LOVED it! It has become my new BBC favorite! Now I absolutely have to read the book.
Talk to you later!
In Christ,
Bonnie Mae
June 26, 2008 at 11:10 pm
I haven’t seen Our Mutual Friend or read the book yet. The only good Di kens adaptations I’ve seen are Nicholas Nickleby Masterpiece Theatre’s David Copperfield.(I’ve seen some movie versions of Oliver Twist, but in my opinion it’s not a good enough book to make a good movie). I’ll have to check that one out.
~Emma
June 28, 2008 at 10:11 am
Have you seen Miss Potter, which is based on the life & love story of Beatrix Potter? It is so lovely & sweet; it’s now one of my favourite movies and I am on a one-girl promotional campaign for it.
~Emma
June 30, 2008 at 12:40 am
No, I really need to see that! I’ve heard it’s really, really good. We’ll have to rent it soon.
June 30, 2008 at 9:31 pm
Your commitment is encouraging to see! I met your dad at the Constitution Party National Convention back in April and told him that I enjoyed your post on his blog about college.
I linked to you on my blog today. Thanks for putting these thoughts out!
July 2, 2008 at 12:00 am
i certainly agree with his article from a purely economic standpoint. (you know my postition) However, it gets really tricky pursuing those alternative means of acquiring a degree when you are studying something very intricate that requires a lot of hands on time. My husband for example, graduated 3 years ago with a Mechanical engineering degree. I do not think he could have accomplished this through correspondence. It’s a hard field and a much needed one. I wonder if you would agree that traditional college/university may well be needed in fields such as these. Medical school also comes to mind.
Thanks for the link though, I love links!
July 3, 2008 at 8:30 am
Bonnie- yes, do watch Miss Potter. It is really, really, really good. My brotheers liked it because it has “Obi Wan Kenobi” in it- but maybe you will find that it has other good points, too
.
~ellie
July 3, 2008 at 11:50 pm
Laura: Yes, I would agree that as the system stands now, college/university is probably necessary for men who wish to enter fields like medicine or engineering. I’ll be interested in reading the series you’re starting on your blog.
Bethany: Nice to hear from you! Daddy told me about y’all meeting. BTW, I checked out your blog and realised I recognised you from Heart Thoughts Retreat. Small world.
~Emma